Hello dear
Welcome To Craig's Cake Shop
Craig's Cake Shop, located in Verona, WI, is a celebrated destination for exquisite desserts and custom cakes. With a commitment to quality and creativity, the shop offers a delightful array of flavors, including classic chocolate and inviting carrot cake. Customers rave about their experiences, praising the attentive service and the shop's ability to bring imaginative cake designs to life. From stunning wedding cakes to fun birthday creations, every detail is crafted with care. Whether you're indulging in a slice or celebrating a special occasion, Craig's Cake Shop's delicious offerings never fail to impress.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Chocolate
Vanilla
Red Velvet
Lemon Poppyseed
Strawberry
Peach
Banana
Pumpkin
Carrot
About
Craig's Cake Shop
Welcome to Craig's Cake Shop, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Verona, Wisconsin. Located at 604 W Verona Ave, this charming bakery specializes in crafting exquisite desserts that are sure to capture your heart and taste buds. You can reach them at (608) 848-6331 for inquiries or to place your order.
At Craig's Cake Shop, the menu boasts a variety of cake flavors that cater to every palate. From classic favorites like Chocolate, Vanilla, and Red Velvet, to the refreshing notes of Lemon Poppyseed and Strawberry, there is something for everyone. For those with more adventurous taste buds, try the unique Chocolate Peanut Butter or the delightful Raspberry Cheesecake.
What truly sets Craig's Cake Shop apart is their commitment to customer satisfaction and high-quality ingredients. Patrons rave about the shop’s stellar service and beautiful cake designs. Corrina R. shared her experience, saying, "Everything about the process was smooth and easy! The cake looked beautiful and was delivered on time! Cake was delicious!!" Such testimonials reflect the shop's dedication to delivering perfection not just in aesthetic, but in flavors as well.
Whether you are celebrating a wedding, a birthday, or simply indulging in a sweet craving, the customer reviews speak volumes. Christian N Jessica K.'s glowing words echo a common theme: "They NAILED it!" Their daughter’s golden birthday cake was not only visually stunning but also a culinary masterpiece.
For the carrot cake lovers, Sho R. and Sue W. emphasized its rich flavor and moist texture. Sue W. enthusiastically noted, “everyone raved about how great the cake was,” affirming Craig’s Cake Shop's reputation in the community.
Beyond traditional cakes, specialty custom orders are a highlight. Hope B. shared an inspiring story about a custom Bluey-themed cake that not only satisfied the themed request but also left everyone wanting more, highlighting the shop’s ability to adapt to last-minute requests and create engaging edible art.
In conclusion, Craig's Cake Shop is more than just a bakery; it's a home for your sweet celebrations. With a warm ambiance, skilled bakers, and a passion for the craft, it is undoubtedly a must-visit for anyone in the Madison area seeking divine desserts. Treat yourself to a piece of their delicious artistry – you won't be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We got our wedding cake and cupcakes here! Everything about the process was smooth and easy! The cake looked beautiful and was delivered on time! Cake was delicious!! ”
“ We ordered this cake for my daughter's golden birthday! I sent them an inspo pic and they NAILED it! I was soooo happy when I picked this up! They were so accommodating and answered all my questions! They were friendly and the lady at the front counter was so sweet! Will definitely be ordering from them again! The carrot cake was amazing! ”
“ I ordered a birthday cake from here. It was a carrot cake with whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings. The cake was beautifully done and was delicious. The shop was neat and quiet. ”
“ We had a carrot cake for a birthday party with over 200 people attending and everyone raved about how great the cake was. even my sister a professor baker said it was awesome‼‼‼ ”
“ If you love Bluey as much as we do you'd understand how the duck cake was a must. Since my strong suit is certainly not baking Craig's Cake Shop made the perfect rendition for us! Not to mention they accommodated a last minute cupcake order add. If your looking for custom cakes in the Madison area we definitely recommend them. Not to mention how tasty it was! ”
“ Craig's has been a staple in our house for years, beginning back in 2014 for our wedding. Since then, we've ordered many birthday and other celebratory cakes. Craig's cakes are not only delicious, but also beautifully decorated! I love the many different flavor options to choose from. My favorite is peach, although any other choice is equally as yummy. The best part about getting a wedding cake from them is that on your first anniversary, you can call and get a fresh top tier made, instead of trying to freeze the original as is tradition. For my son and daughter's 1st birthdays they also received a free smash cake with the purchase of a standard size. Hard to beat that! ”
“ We wanted a special cake for my baby's first birthday. We were hosting on a Badger football Saturday so we really wanted a Bucky cake. We found Craig's has the official licenses to reproduce the UW copyright images like Bucky and the motion W. Got a round red velvet cake and everyone said it was moist and delicious. Baby got a free Smash cake that was plain vanilla with whipped cream frosting - it was huge! Very happy with my purchase. ”
“ If you dream of cake this is the place for you. Cupcakes, small cakes, wedding cakes and everything in between. Our favorite is the carrot cake with white chocolate frosting. Incredibly moist and flavorful frosted with cheesecake mousse and white chocolate curls! Mini cakes are available frozen for the spur of the moment indulgence all others are made to order. Covid rules mean you call when you get there, stay in your car, they bring out the cake, pay and go. ”
